Minimal Match — 35% match
based on chemical composition and mechanical property overlap.
SAE J404 5150 (SAE J404:2009) and IS 11169 (Part 1) 10Ni5Cr4 (IS 11169 (Part 1):2022) are both steel grades.
Both fall under the Alloy Steel category.
SAE J404 5150 is typically used for chemistry-only alloy steel grade; see the composition notes for product scope, while IS 11169 (Part 1) 10Ni5Cr4 is commonly used for cold heading and cold extrusion of parts that are case hardened; the standard covers bars, wire rods and wires of 2 to 100 mm (clause 1.1, annex b).
SAE J404 5150 is defined under SAE International, originating from United States, while IS 11169 (Part 1) 10Ni5Cr4 is defined under Bureau of Indian Standards (IS), originating from India.
As per chemical composition, SAE J404 5150 vs IS 11169 (Part 1) 10Ni5Cr4 is a 65.3% match.
Mechanical property data is not available for both grades, so this factor could not be scored.
Combined, this makes them a minimal match overall at 35%.
Matched by chemical composition and mechanical properties, not a formal equivalence claim. Always verify against the applicable standard before substitution.
Mechanical Properties
Property
SAE J404 5150
IS 11169 (Part 1) 10Ni5Cr4
Hardness, ferrite-pearlite (+FP)
Not specified
137-187 HB
Tensile Strength, annealed (+AC)
Not specified
<=520 MPa (over 5 to 40 mm)
Typical Applications
SAE J404 5150
Chemistry-only alloy steel grade; see the composition notes for product scope
IS 11169 (Part 1) 10Ni5Cr4
Cold heading and cold extrusion of parts that are case hardened; the standard covers bars, wire rods and wires of 2 to 100 mm (clause 1.1, Annex B)
Key Differences
IS 11169 (Part 1) 10Ni5Cr4 specifies Cu, Ni which are not specified for SAE J404 5150.
Can SAE J404 5150 Be Substituted With IS 11169 (Part 1) 10Ni5Cr4?
SAE J404 5150 and IS 11169 (Part 1) 10Ni5Cr4 share some compositional similarity but differ enough that substitution should not be assumed. Review the differences above carefully, and consult the applicable standard or a metallurgist before using one in place of the other.
What is the difference between SAE J404 5150 and IS 11169 (Part 1) 10Ni5Cr4?
IS 11169 (Part 1) 10Ni5Cr4 specifies Cu, Ni which are not specified for SAE J404 5150.
Can SAE J404 5150 be substituted with IS 11169 (Part 1) 10Ni5Cr4?
SAE J404 5150 and IS 11169 (Part 1) 10Ni5Cr4 share some compositional similarity but differ enough that substitution should not be assumed. Review the differences above carefully, and consult the applicable standard or a metallurgist before using one in place of the other.